Is TMS the Same as ECT?

Matt Rodriguez • March 3, 2025

TMS vs. ECT: Comparing Mental Health Treatments at TMS Ketamine Clinic of SW Florida

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) are both innovative treatments for mental health disorders, particularly for individuals who haven’t found success with conventional therapies. While both methods involve stimulating brain activity, they differ significantly in their techniques, side effects, and suitability for various conditions. Understanding these distinctions can help you determine which treatment might be the best fit for you.


How Does TMS Work? 

TMS is a non-invasive treatment that uses magnetic pulses to activate nerve cells in targeted brain regions. In depression, TMS targets the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), an area that is often underactive in people with mood disorders. By stimulating these certain regions, TMS enhances the electrical activity of nerve cells and promotes the release of chemical messengers in the brain. 

TMS has also been shown to increase functional connectivity, which is how brain areas interact. This allows new signaling patterns to form, helping people more easily re-shape negative thoughts and behaviors. 


How is TMS Administered?

TMS sessions involve placing a magnetic coil on the scalp over the targeted brain regions. The procedure is done while you’re awake, typically in an outpatient setting, without the need for anesthesia. Each session lasts about 30 to 40 minutes, and patients are generally safe to go home after the treatment has finished. Most patients undergo 20 to 30 sessions over four to six weeks.


How Does ECT Work? 

ECT is a more invasive procedure that uses controlled electrical currents to induce a brief seizure in the brain. Like TMS, this increases electrical activity and the release of chemical messengers in the brain, potentially activating regions that are damaged or dysfunctional in mental health disorders. Unlike TMS, ECT stimulates the whole brain as opposed to targeted brain regions.


How is ECT Administered?

ECT is administered under general anesthesia, with electrodes placed on the scalp to deliver the electrical stimulation. The entire process, including preparation and recovery, takes about an hour, though the seizure lasts only 30 to 60 seconds.

ECT treatments are normally given twice a week. On average, patients receive around ten sessions in total. However, treatment administration will vary depending on an individual's unique treatment response. 


TMS vs. ECT: Key Differences

Treatment Process

  • TMS: Non-invasive and performed in an outpatient setting. Patients remain fully awake, and no anesthesia or recovery time is needed. Treatments occur over several weeks.
  • ECT: Requires general anesthesia and is typically administered 2 to 3 times per week for 6 to 12 sessions. Recovery time is needed after each session due to anesthesia and the induced seizure.

Effectiveness

  • TMS: Effective for moderate to severe mental health conditions, with noticeable improvements within weeks of starting treatment. It’s particularly suited for individuals who haven’t responded to traditional therapies.
  • ECT: Highly effective for severe, treatment-resistant depression (TRD), bipolar disorder, and other conditions with life-threatening symptoms and provides rapid relief.

Side Effects

  • TMS: Typically mild and temporary, including headaches, scalp discomfort, or lightheadedness. Rarely, seizures or hearing issues may occur.
  • ECT: Side effects are more pronounced and may include short-term memory loss, confusion, fatigue, and headaches. Long-term cognitive issues or memory problems may arise, particularly after numerous rounds of treatment. 


Who Is a Good Candidate for Each Treatment?

Mental Health Conditions

  • TMS: TMS is FDA-approved for depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and addiction. It is generally recommended when front-line treatments, such as antidepressants, have failed.
  • ECT: ECT is FDA-approved for depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and catatonia. It is generally recommended as a last resort or when life-threatening symptoms require immediate intervention.

Treatment History

  • TMS: Suitable for individuals who haven’t achieved success with antidepressants or psychotherapy. It’s also effective for addiction when other therapies haven’t worked.
  • ECT: Typically used when multiple other treatments, including TMS, have failed, or when rapid symptom relief is crucial.

Medical Eligibility

  • TMS: Since it doesn’t involve anesthesia, it’s safer for individuals with certain medical conditions.
  • ECT: Requires a medical evaluation for anesthesia, making it less accessible for individuals with significant cardiovascular or respiratory issues.


Explore TMS Treatment Options at TMS Ketamine Clinic of SW Florida

At the TMS Ketamine Clinic of SW Florida, we’re committed to providing advanced mental health treatments, including TMS therapy, to help you achieve lasting wellness. Our compassionate team develops personalized treatment plans tailored to your unique needs, ensuring you receive the best possible care.

In addition to TMS, we offer complementary therapies, including medication management, designed to enhance your recovery journey and promote long-term mental health benefits. If you’re seeking effective treatment for depression, we’re here to support you every step of the way.

To learn more, book a free consultation with our team today. Let us help you take the next step toward a brighter future.

BOOK A CONSULTATION

Knowing that you are not alone is of utmost importance. Seek assistance for depression today!

CONTACT US

OUR SERVICE SUPPORTS MENTAL WELLNESS

  • Depression
  • Lack of Joy
  • Sadness and Despair
  • Low Mood
  • Lethargy
  • Insomnia
  • Oversleeping
  • Social Isolation
  • Self-Harm
  • Substance Abuse
  • Suicidal Ideation
  • Alcoholism
By Matt Rodriguez April 1, 2025
Spravato (esketamine) is a groundbreaking treatment for individuals with treatment-resistant depression (TRD) and major depressive disorder with suicidal ideation (MDSI). Unlike traditional antidepressants, Spravato works rapidly, often providing symptom relief within hours. In this article, we’ll introduce Spravato, discuss how long it takes to work, and explore its short- and long-term effects. What is Spravato and How Does It Work? Spravato (esketamine) is an FDA-approved nasal spray derived from ketamine, specifically designed to treat individuals with TRD and MDSI. Like ketamine, Spravato works by inhibiting NMDA receptors —proteins involved in learning and memory. This inhibition leads to the release of glutamate, a key neurotransmitter, triggering several downstream effects in brain cells. Unlike standard antidepressants, Spravato has rapid-acting effects, sometimes appearing almost immediately after use. It also offers sustained benefits compared to conventional medications and doesn’t require daily use. Short- and Long-Term Effects of Spravato on the Brain Immediate Effects Spravato enhances activity in brain regions responsible for mood regulation, which are often underactive in depression. This effect can occur within hours, often within 24 hours, leading to symptom relief and an improved mood. Long-Term Effects Over time, repeated doses of Spravato strengthen connections between nerve cells through neuroplasticity . Spravato stimulates the production of proteins that support this process, reinforcing neural circuits linked to mood and emotional regulation. Neuroplasticity may explain Spravato’s prolonged improvements in depression. How Long Does It Take for Spravato to Work? Clinical trials have shown that Spravato can quickly reduce symptoms of depression, often within hours or days. In a study of adults with TRD, those who took Spravato along with an antidepressant experienced noticeable symptom relief within 24 hours—an improvement greater than those who took a placebo with an antidepressant. Both groups continued improving over the next 28 days, but the difference between them remained significant. For people with MDSI, clinical studies have shown that Spravato, combined with an antidepressant, significantly reduces symptoms within 24 hours compared to placebo groups. The greatest differences are seen within four hours of taking the medication. Factors That Affect How Long Spravato Takes to Work The time it takes for Spravato to start working varies from person to person. Some may feel relief within hours, while others may require several treatments over days or weeks to notice significant changes. Factors that influence how quickly Spravato works include: Severity of Depression – Those with more severe symptoms may take longer to notice improvement. Individual Brain Chemistry – Differences in neurotransmitter activity can affect response time. Previous Treatments – If someone has had multiple unsuccessful treatments, their response may be slower. Overall Health – Chronic illnesses or nutritional deficiencies may impact treatment effectiveness. Psychological and Environmental Factors – Stress levels, support systems, and therapy participation can all play a role. How Long Do the Effects of Spravato Last? A single dose of Spravato provides relief for up to 24 hours, but for sustained benefits, treatment follows a structured regimen: Induction Phase Twice-weekly doses for the first four weeks. Maintenance Phase Begins after Week 4, with dosing frequency gradually reduced based on clinical response—typically shifting to once weekly or every two weeks. A long-term study found that 35.6% of patients achieved remission after the induction phase , and 46.1% remained in remission during the maintenance phase . On average, patients in the maintenance phase had used Spravato for just over three years, indicating its continued benefits with long-term use. Spravato Short-Term Side Effects While Spravato is generally well tolerated, mild side effects are common, including: Dizziness Nausea Sedation or drowsiness Dissociation (feeling detached from one’s body or reality) Increased blood pressure Anxiety or restlessness Elevated mood or euphoria These side effects typically wear off within a few hours but can linger for up to 24 hours. Safety Considerations Monitoring : Spravato is administered in a certified healthcare setting under medical supervision. Patients are monitored for at least two hours post-dose for potential side effects. Driving Restrictions : Due to possible sedation and dissociation, patients should not drive or operate heavy machinery until the following day after a full night’s rest. Potential Long-Term Risks of Spravato Ketamine is a drug of abuse with addictive properties. Chronic misuse has been linked to long-term effects such as cognitive impairment and damage to the bladder, liver, and kidneys. However, Spravato is administered in a controlled clinical environment, significantly reducing the risk of misuse . While it has not been extensively studied in patients with pre-existing substance abuse disorders, those with addiction histories may be at higher risk. Physically, Spravato appears safe for long-term use , though some evidence suggests users may experience bladder-related symptoms. However, clinical trials have found no significant difference in bladder infections between Spravato and non-Spravato patients. Spravato Treatment at SW Florida TMS & Ketamine Clinic At Southwest Florida TMS & Ketamine Clinic , we specialize in innovative depression treatments , including Spravato therapy for individuals with TRD. If you’re struggling with depression and haven’t found relief from conventional therapy, our services, based in Fort Myers, could have the solution you need. Spravato is a fast-acting medication with sustained benefits, and our team is highly experienced in delivering this medicine with expert care. If you choose to have treatment at our service, we will closely monitor you during and after administration and will be here to provide support after and between doses. For more information on Spravato treatment and to schedule a consultation, visit our Spravato Clinic page . Key Takeaways Rapid Relief: Many patients experience symptom improvement within hours or days of starting Spravato. Mechanism of Action: Spravato enhances mood-regulating brain activity and promotes neuroplasticity. Individual Variability: Factors like depression severity, brain chemistry, and past treatments influence response time. Sustained Benefits: With continued treatment, Spravato strengthens neural connections, supporting long-term depression relief. Safety Considerations: While generally well-tolerated, Spravato requires medical supervision due to potential side effects and driving restrictions. Expert Care at SW Florida TMS & Ketamine Clinic: Offering specialized Spravato therapy with close monitoring and personalized treatment plans for patients with TRD.
By Kimberly Mercille January 23, 2025
Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) is a non-invasive therapy offering hope to individuals who have struggled to find relief through medications or therapy alone. In this article, we’ll explore what TMS is and why it’s a safe, effective option for addressing various mental health challenges.
A person is sitting on a couch using a cell phone looking for help with depression.
By Dr. Zaheer Aslam December 23, 2024
If you’ve been searching help with depression near Fort Myers Florida, we break down what ketamine is, how it works for depression, and what you should know.
A woman is sitting in front of a lake with her hand on her forehead.
By Dr. Zaheer Aslam November 21, 2024
Explore effective treatment options and strategies for anxiety disorders. Gain insights to manage symptoms and improve your mental health. We can help!
A woman is standing on a pier with her arms outstretched at sunset in Fort Myers.
By Dr. Zaheer Aslam October 21, 2024
Lets explore the nuances of depression, including whether it can truly disappear without intervention. Contact us for local depression help in Fort Myers.
A man is holding his head in his hands.
By Dr. Zaheer Aslam September 22, 2024
Ignoring signs of mental distress can lead to consequences. This post will help you identify key indicators that it’s time to prioritize your mental health.
See More Posts